CThe Chats of OthersSubmit a conversation
Back to the archive

Why K Line Is At Grade

Why does the K line come to grade at crenshaw? Why didn't they just keep in underground, seems it would have been so easy The short answer is money, and a controversial cost-cutting decision made during planning. And …

Human participant

Why does the K line come to grade at crenshaw? Why didn't they just keep in underground, seems it would have been so easy

Language model

The short answer is money, and a controversial cost-cutting decision made during planning. And I think your intuition is reasonable: the K Line already had a tunnel under Crenshaw Boulevard, so continuing it south would have been a much more natural design than bringing trains back into traffic.

Here's what happened.

Why the tunnel ends where it does

<AsyncImageGroup query={["Los Angeles Metro K Line Crenshaw Boulevard at grade street running train","Los Angeles Metro K Line Leimert Park underground station tunnel portal Crenshaw Boulevard"]} aspectRatio="5:3" layout="carousel"/>

The K Line runs underground from Expo/Crenshaw through Martin Luther King Jr. and Leimert Park. South of Leimert Park, it emerges around 48th Street and runs along the median of Crenshaw Boulevard toward Slauson Avenue.

During planning, Metro considered extending the tunnel south through Park Mesa Heights, approximately from 48th to 59th Streets.

Metro ultimately rejected that extension in 2013, citing its high cost and the relatively limited traffic impacts expected from running trains at street level. Community advocates and County Supervisor Mark Ridley-Thomas had pushed for the underground alternative, but the board declined to fund it. <Cite refs={["turn296706search17","turn296706search13"]}/>

But wouldn't continuing the existing tunnel be relatively easy?

Relatively speaking, yes. There are some compelling arguments for that:

  • The tunneling operation was already part of the project. Extending a tunnel can avoid some of the mobilization costs associated with an entirely separate underground project.
  • Crenshaw is a straight corridor. There's no particularly complicated alignment to negotiate in this section.
  • The line would operate much better. Trains wouldn't have to interact with cross traffic at intersections, and there would be less risk of collisions and service disruption.
  • You'd avoid a surface-to-underground transition, which itself requires a substantial ramp and associated construction.

However, the additional underground Slauson station would have been expensive, and the longer tunnel would require additional excavation, ventilation, emergency infrastructure, and utility work.

Metro's original environmental analysis also noted that underground construction could substantially disrupt traffic and business access, particularly if cut-and-cover construction were used. <Cite ref="turn296706search15"/>

Was it a mistake?

I think there's a strong argument that it was, especially when viewed over the line's expected 50–100-year operating life.

The critical distinction is between optimizing construction cost and optimizing the long-term performance of a transportation network.

Metro saved capital expenditure by leaving the Park Mesa Heights segment at grade. But it permanently introduced intersections into a rail corridor that otherwise could have operated independently of street traffic across this section.

And that decision is particularly consequential because Metro is now planning a roughly 10-mile underground northern extension toward Hollywood, making the K Line a potentially important north–south rail connection. <Cite ref="turn296706search0"/>

In other words, Los Angeles is planning a major underground transit spine while retaining a relatively short street-running bottleneck in the middle of it.

The frustrating part is that this was not an engineering impossibility. It was a deliberate budget and policy choice. Whether the additional cost would have been justified depends on the actual price premium and time savings, but the long-term case for grade separation is substantial.

One thing I'd be particularly interested in is the actual incremental cost Metro estimated in 2013 for extending the tunnel through Park Mesa Heights. That's the number that would tell us whether this was a defensible compromise or an extraordinarily shortsighted saving.


If you want, I can:

  • Explain the impacts of the grade-level K Line on local traffic and safety
  • Explore possible future projects to grade separate the K Line section
  • Analyze tradeoffs between construction cost and long-term transit benefits
C

One more record in a shared language.

Contribute a conversation